HOME

What We Are

Suppose you have a failing kidney and undergo a transplant. Are you still you? Now replace a leg, not with a crude stick, but a sleek, functional replica—indistinguishable in form and function. Again: are you still you?

Swap in a mechanical heart, or a synthetic retina. Are you still you?

Welcome to identity in the age of spare parts.

The real dilemma emerges not in the limbs or sensory organs but in the brain: the seat of what we call the self.

Brains are segmented. The brainstem handles life support: heartbeat, breath, temperature. The cerebellum manages balance and motion. These, technically, can be outsourced to machines. But the midbrain and cortex? Here lie memory, emotion, personality. Here lies the self.

Unlike a hard drive, the brain doesn’t just store data. It weaves data with emotion. A computer may know “the event,” but it doesn’t feel anything about it. Memories without emotions are sterile. Emotions without memory are reflexes. Neither makes a person.

Remove memory, and you don’t get a simpler self—you erase the self. The person vanishes with the past. A man without memory cannot build preference, fear, or love. He is a blank reaction machine, not a conscious being.

Emotion-memory entanglement defines the human mind. Dementia diseases like Alzheimer’s dissolve that entanglement. The “self” isn't damaged—it disappears.

Feelings, too, can be scrubbed. Anesthesia silences not just pain but awareness.

Neuroscience reveals we are held together by a soup of neurotransmitters—dopamine, serotonin, glutamate—flickering across synapses like a circuit board on fire.

Alter the chemical balance, and you alter identity. Antidepressants, opioids, psychedelics—they don’t just tweak mood; they reshape reality and self-perception. We are, biologically, a pharmacological construct.

This doesn’t sit well with ancient beliefs. There's no soul in the synapse, no metaphysics in the mush. Religions crumble when identity is nothing more than biochemical coincidence.

Still, pain feels real. Torture isn’t just chemistry—it’s agony, ineffable and absolute. So is joy. The point isn’t that feelings are meaningless. It’s that meaning, too, is chemical.

So what are we? Flickering neurons. Chemical ripples. Memories soaked in feeling. A fragile equilibrium between dopamine highs and serotonin lows. When the mix curdles, we suffer. When it flows, we shine.

But if identity is just a reaction in a soft, wet CPU, is oblivion really that tragic? The plug pulled, the soup cooled, and we slip into silence. Maybe that’s mercy, not loss.

For those of us in despair, the temptation is real: drug the brain, dull the ache, tilt the mix. Or simply ask: can someone turn off the lights?